'Film archive storage' found at https://flic.kr/p/aUg8cx by DRs Kulturarvsprojekt (https://flickr.com/people/kulturarvsprojektet) used under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/)
'Film archive storage' found at https://flic.kr/p/aUg8cx by DRs Kulturarvsprojekt (https://flickr.com/people/kulturarvsprojektet) used under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/)
'Film archive storage' found at https://flic.kr/p/aUg8cx by DRs Kulturarvsprojekt (https://flickr.com/people/kulturarvsprojektet) used under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/)

An LLC (Limited Liability Company) Member in Massachusetts has a right to inspect certain records of the LLC. This includes basic information, such as the certificate of organization, the names and addresses of all Members and Managers, and a copy of the operating agreement.

Minority LLC Members who feel that they are being oppressed or frozen out will want to obtain as much information as possible, including especially financial information. A Massachusetts LLC must, by statute, have an office in the Commonwealth where it must keep certain records. These records include the following:

  1. Income tax returns for last three years; and

  2. Financial Statements, if any, for the last three years.

Any Member of the LLC shall be allowed to inspect and copy the records, at that member's expense, and at reasonable times. Subject to the provisions of the Operating Agreement or standards set by the Manager(s), each Member shall also be allowed to obtain “true and full information regarding the state of the business and financial condition of the limited liability company, [. . . inluding] other information regarding the affairs of the limited liability company as is just and reasonable.” M.G.L. c. 156C, Sec. 10.  How to determine what is "just and reasonable?"  The wise majority owners should develop uniform standards regarding access to documents to prevent a claim of unfair treatment by the minority owner. The test is whether a request is “reasonably related” to the Member's interest. A minority owner that makes repeated and numerous requests may be seen as being a pest or having an ulterior motive. By contrast, a Delaware court (addressing a similar statute) ruled that the following were “proper purposes” for requesting documents from the LLC: (1) putting a valuation on one's ownership interest; and (2) investigating potential wrongdoing by the majority.

If the majority owners refuse a request for information, the minority owner must determine what action to take. There are no “LLC Police” to call. A minority owner will have to file suit to obtain the documents it wants. If there are enough facts to support such a claim, a minority owner can also bring a claim for a freeze out, which occurs when the majority owners violate their fiduciary duties to the minority owner and frustrate her reasonable expectations of ownership.  A Member's ownership interest in an LLC is considered personal property and a Member is entitled to obtain an accounting from a fellow Member, but you will have to file suit for an accounting. At least one Massachusetts court has held that a Member of an LLC is entitled to an accounting from a controlling Member or Manager where there is a fiduciary relationship between the parties. By contrast, there is no right to an accounting against the LLC itself because there is no fiduciary duty owed by the LLC to the Members.

The rights to records of a minority shareholder of a Massachusetts corporation are similar, but not identical to the rights of an LLC Member. A shareholder should be able to articulate specific facts regarding possible mismanagement or wrongdoing by the controlling interest in order to see financial records, meeting minutes and other business records (other than the basics).

The takeaway is to first check the Operating Agreement or Shareholder Agreement or other company documents and then the statute to determine what documents a minority owner is entitled to. Both sides should consider carefully whether their dispute over records can be resolved without resorting to litigation. Perhaps an independent mediator could help the parties resolve their dispute before both sides incur substantial legal fees.  In other situations, someone is being unreasonable or someone is hiding something. This is a recipe for contentious litigation, so you better lawyer up if you think that the minority owner is being unreasonable or has an ulterior motive, or if you think that the majority is hiding something. As always, this post contains general information in a cursory fashion and is not legal advice.

By Adam P. Whitney, Esq.

617.338.7000