How do Limited Liability Company Operating Agreements affect the fiduciary duties owed to co-Members of the LLC? That issue was decided in the case of Butts v. Freedman, which also involved Boston Equity Advisors LLC (“BEA”) and Outcome Capital, LLC (“Outcome”).
Mr. Butts and Mr. Freedman co-owned BEA. They were the founders and held equal ownership. A third defendant, Mr. Ben-Joseph worked at BEA as an independent contractor. Butts and Fredman began having disagreements with one another, mostly about Ben-Joseph’s compensation. Freedman and Ben-Joseph decided to leave BEA and join Outcome, a competing enterprise.
At first, there were discussions of merging BEA and Outcome. Freedman and Ben-Joseph did not inform Butts of their meeting and discussions with Outcome. After Butts found out that Freedman and Ben-Joseph joined Outcome, he/BEA sued for breach of fiduciary duty against Freedman (and another claim not relevant to this post against both Freedman and Ben-Joseph).
Why Butts/BEA Lost:
The Appeals Court agreed that Freedman owed Butts and BEA fiduciary duties. The Appeals Court explained that under Massachusetts law “fiduciaries may plan to compete with the entity to which they owe allegiance, provided that in the course of such arrangements they do not otherwise act in violation of their fiduciary duties.”
The question of whether Freedman “otherwise acted in violation of [his] fiduciary duties” depended on the interpretation of the Operating Agreement. Specifically, the Operating Agreement of the LLC broadly provided that Members may engage in other business ventures and investment opportunities. Notably, there was not a non-compete provision in the Operating Agreement or otherwise.
The Appeals Court ruled that the language of the Operating Agreement limited the fiduciary duty of Freedman such that he had no duty to disclose the Outcome opportunity or to share the Opportunity with Butts or BEA.
Freedman made cogent arguments that the language was just boilerplate and that literal application would allow members to take corporate opportunities away from their LLC. However, the Appeals Court essentially ruled that the freedom to contract overrode those concerns. Freedman prevailed in his defense.
The lesson here is that the words of an Operating Agreement matter. Some people think that they are “standard” and that they are all boilerplate. But what do you think will happen when your business partner has disagreements and they go to a lawyer? The lawyer will parse through each sentence of the Operating Agreement to find language that will support your opponent in a lawsuit. So Operating Agreements don’t matter. Until they do.
If you are are going into an LLC, read the proposed Operating Agreement carefully and strongly consider having a lawyer review it with you. It’s important to understand your business and your goals because each situation is unique. I get that it seems like an unnecessary expense when you are starting a business, but you could be dooming yourself for failure if you don’t pay attention to the details.
If you already have an Operating Agreement and you are having disputes with your co-owners, have a qualified lawyer review the language to see what leverage you have. Or, maybe you can renegotiate and enter a new Operating Agreement.
Adam P. Whitney
Fine print: the above is not legal advice, but general information. I cannot provide legal advice without a written fee agreement and a full review of your legal matter.
CONNECT WITH ADAM
RELATED PRACTICE AREAS
ADAM’S RECENT POSTS
Baby, It’s Cold Outside: Protecting Your Rights in LLC and Close Corporation Freeze-Outs in Massachusetts
Just like the bracing chill of a Massachusetts winter, experiencing a corporate freeze-out can feel cold and harsh. Whether you're part of a Limited Liability Company (LLC), partnership or a close corporation in Massachusetts, a thorough understanding of freeze-out...
A Business Breakup: How to Navigate a Toxic Business Partnership and Safeguard your Financial and Mental Health
Your business partnership started with a shared vision and enthusiasm, much like a marriage. But as many business owners know, partnerships can sour, making your daily operations a nightmare. If you find yourself as a minority owner or majority shareholder in an...
Sometimes bloodlines blur business lines. There's a potent blend of emotion and finance in family businesses. I've been in the trenches, witnessing brothers at odds with brothers, sons challenging fathers, and sibling rivalries taken to the extreme. A wise judge once...
Any lawyer worth their salt can dissect a noncompetition agreement and under Massachusetts law, predict its enforceability. Indeed, this forms the bedrock of sound legal advice, but it is merely the beginning. The real challenge lies in the practical and strategic...
When deciding whether to sign a separation agreement or severance agreement with your employer, consider the following issues: Consideration: What are you getting for your signature? What are you giving up? Is the trade-off worth it? Waiver of legal rights:...
GET IN TOUCH
Law Office of Adam P. Whitney265 Franklin Street, Suite 1702
Boston, MA 02110
ABOUT THE FIRM
Business Litigation and Employment Law
Outside General Counsel
Shareholder / LLC / Partnership Disputes
No attorney-client relationship is established by your use of this site. You must not send or share any confidential information about you or any legal issue without Attorney Whitney's express written permission. The content of this website may be considered advertising for legal services under the laws and rules of professional conduct. The content does not constitute legal advice. The content is for information purposes only. Legal advice cannot be provided unless you hire my firm and we perform a full review of the legal matter and the most current, applicable law. The law in your state may be different than Massachusetts, so the information in the content may be completely irrelevant if you are outside of Massachusetts.